SportingSmiles wins on price at $115 for its Dual Laminate guard. Pro Teeth Guard is $199.99, but publishes a stronger headline protection proposition: a 60-day 110% refund promise plus a 1-year wear-and-tear warranty. SportingSmiles publishes a 90-day warranty and 100% satisfaction guarantee.
Side-by-side
| Pro Teeth Guard Hybrid | SportingSmiles Dual Laminate | |
|---|---|---|
| Current price | $199.99 | $115 |
| Impression kit | Included | Included |
| U.S. shipping | Check current checkout terms | Free shipping stated |
| Published buyer protection | 60-day 110% refund promise; 1-year wear-and-tear warranty | 90-day warranty; 100% satisfaction guarantee |
| Positioning | Moderate/heavy grinding | Heavy grinding; soft inner/hard outer |
Where the $85 premium could be justified
If a buyer values Pro Teeth Guard's longer published warranty and refund framing enough to reduce perceived fit/durability risk, the higher upfront price can be rational. If both products last the same length of time for that user, SportingSmiles is substantially cheaper.
Where the comparison breaks down
Actual night-guard lifespan is personal. Grinding severity, material, fit, chewing habits and care can dominate price. Neither company's marketing can tell an individual reader exactly how long a guard will last.
Model the long-run cost
Change the replacement interval. If the premium guard lasts longer, its cost gap narrows; if lifespan is equal, SportingSmiles remains much cheaper.
| Night guard | 1 year | 2 years | 3 years | Assumption |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pro Teeth Guard Hybrid Verified 2026-09-06 | $199.99 | $399.98 | $399.98 | Replace every 18 months. Source |
| SportingSmiles Dual Laminate Verified 2026-09-06 | $115.00 | $230.00 | $230.00 | Replace every 18 months. Source |
Change the assumptions
Use a preset, then change any number. This is a cost model—not a recommendation about how often a dental appliance or brush head should be replaced.