Remi currently has the most aggressive entry offer at $99 for two guards through its club model, with $89 replacement sets advertised. ClearRetain and SportingSmiles remain strong low-cost one-time options, while Pro Teeth Guard costs more but offers more guard types and a strong published guarantee.
Remi
Two custom guards under the current club offer, with $89 replacement sets advertised.
Check RemiClearRetain
Low upfront pricing across soft and hard custom options.
Check ClearRetainSportingSmiles
Several material choices around the $110–$120 range.
Check SportingSmilesPro Teeth Guard
Soft, hybrid, ultra-thin and hard options with a strong published guarantee.
Check Pro Teeth GuardSentinel Mouthguards
Sentinel’s Hybrid Guard uses a soft inner layer with a hard outer layer and is positioned for moderate-to-severe grinders. Compare its fit/remake terms and total cost against the other custom options.
Check Sentinel Hybrid GuardTeethNightGuard.com
The Extra Durable 3mm custom night guard is the brand’s most-recommended model and is positioned for moderate-to-severe grinding and clenching. Compare fit, remake, shipping and warranty terms before ordering.
Check TeethNightGuard.comiHome Dental
iHome Dental currently lists a custom hard-acrylic night guard at $398. That is well above the price-first options in this comparison, so compare the fit, remake and material terms rather than treating it as a budget pick.
Check iHome Dental night guardPick the buying path before you pick the brand
| Your situation | Start with | What matters most |
|---|---|---|
| Price-first, one-time purchase | ClearRetain / SportingSmiles | Material choice + fit/remake terms + shipping |
| Expect regular replacements | Remi | Subscription economics + replacement cadence + cancellation terms |
| Need more material choices | Pro Teeth Guard / SportingSmiles | Soft vs hybrid vs hard recommendation |
| Guard feels too tight or unstable | Fix the fit problem first | Do not solve a fit problem by choosing a thicker material |
| Veneers or major cosmetic restorations | Night guard for veneers | Current tooth contours + bite + clinician material recommendation |
Current price comparison
Best subscription value: Remi
Remi currently advertises $99 for two custom guards under its club offer, with replacement sets at $89 every six months. That makes it especially attractive for buyers who expect to replace guards regularly and are comfortable with a subscription model.
Best one-time value: SportingSmiles
SportingSmiles currently lists a soft guard at $110, dual laminate at $115, and flexible super-hard guard at $120. Its product line also includes thinner guards, back-cut options and retainer/night-guard hybrids, which gives buyers more options for different wear preferences and grinding severity.
Best consumer protection: Pro Teeth Guard
Pro Teeth Guard's Hybrid is $199.99, Soft $179.99, and Hard $219.99. The company states a 60-day 110% money-back guarantee, pays return shipping, and includes a 1-year warranty. Its Hybrid is marketed for moderate-to-heavy grinding; Hard for heavy-to-severe grinding.
Cheapest verified option: ClearRetain
ClearRetain's official collection showed a hard night guard at $99 promotional, a dual-layer hard-soft guard at $104, and a soft guard at $89 in our latest update. Sale pricing can change, but ClearRetain remains one of the lowest-cost custom options in our current comparison.
What matters most
Fit/remake terms, material options, warranty, replacement cost, turnaround time, customer support and price matter more than a flashy product page. The right material still depends on your grinding pattern and dental needs.
If you have veneers, crowns or recent dental work
Do not assume your pre-treatment guard still fits correctly after restorations change tooth contours or bite contacts. Start with our night guard for veneers guide, and have a dentist assess a restoration or bite that already feels wrong before ordering another appliance.
Compare one-time vs replacement economics
A cheap first guard can lose its advantage if remakes, shipping or replacement pricing are weak. Compare the full ownership path.
Compare fit and material before ordering
Soft vs hard night guard · Upper vs lower night guard · Night guard vs retainer
Compare the current price, refund/remake terms, what is included, and the total cost after retainers or replacements. Details can change, so confirm the offer on the provider's site before checkout.
How Dental Verdicts compares products →Source trail
- ClearRetain: Hard Night Guard
- SportingSmiles: Soft Night Guard
- SportingSmiles: Dual Laminate Night Guard
- Pro Teeth Guard: Soft Night Guard
- Pro Teeth Guard: Hybrid Night Guard
- Pro Teeth Guard: Hard Night Guard
- Remi: Custom Night Guards — Club offer